About food brands, consumer control and the economy of attention
When older generations tell of food brands, it is usually associated with war, scarcity or poverty. Butter stamps, bread cards, sugar assignments — symbols of a time when food was not naturally available. The state stepped between man and food. It was no longer money alone that decided on access, but a system of allowances, quotas and administration.
Historically, this was mostly due to a real shortage situation. The supply should be stabilised, social unrest prevented and limited resources distributed as closely as possible. Whether these systems were just or authoritarian depended on time, place and political order. But their origin was at least primarily in material necessity.
On the other hand, considering modern discount landscapes of large food chains — pickerls, apps, point programs, digital coupons, collection systems, cashback campaigns — the comparison seems inappropriate at first. The shelves are full. Nobody rations bread. No one gets a piece of butter only against state brands.
And yet many people have a peculiar sense of structural resemblance.
Because even today, there is increasingly something between man and food.
Not scarcity—but system integration.
⸻
Previously, the logic was:
There aren't enough goods available.
Today, it often sounds like this:
"There are enough goods, but purchasing power and prices must be controlled algorithmically.
This shifts the nature of the mediation. Modern discount and loyalty systems primarily serve not just distribution, but:
- customer loyalty
- the data acquisition
- price control
- margin optimization
- behavioral control
The most important thing is less the discount itself than the condition of the discount.
Not:
Food is cheaper.
But:
"Food is cheaper if you behave properly.
The customer should:
- Using apps
- Earn points.
- Review prospectuses.
- Compare offers.
- Data sharing
- Adjust shopping habits.
- Combining several markets
- Consume in a time-optimized manner.
The price thus becomes not only an economic, but an organizational task.
⸻
This will be particularly problematic where these systems are no longer merely a bonus, but become in fact necessary to keep basic daily care affordable.
Then there is a silent shift: No longer alone money determines quality of life, but in addition the ability to permanently micro-optimize everyday life.
And this is where the subject touches on a deeper social level.
Because people not only have a different amount of capital, but also a different amount:
- Time
- Attention.
- psychic energy
- Concentration
- Organizational reserve.
Discount architectures reward especially those who possess enough of them.
Poverty, on the other hand, often produces precisely the opposite:
- Stress
- Exhaustion
- Time shortage
- Overwhelm
- Short-term.
Those who have multiple jobs, care for children or are mentally exhausted often have less capacity to manage three apps, compare actions, or strategically distribute the weekly shopping across four stores.
This creates a paradoxical situation: Those most in need of relief often have to spend the greatest amount of extra organisational effort to achieve the same prices as better-placed consumers with more time and cognitive reserve.
In the social economy, the term "poverty penalty" is sometimes used here — not only as a financial burden, but as a burden of additional friction.
Poverty doesn't just cost money. Poverty costs attention.
⸻
The real sophistication of modern consumer systems lies in the fact that they are voluntary.
No one's forcing anyone to collect points. No one's forcing anyone to the app.
And yet a reality creeps up in which those without integration into the system effectively pay higher prices.
Two people are often in the same supermarket today and pay different amounts for the same product, depending on:
- App usage
- Purchase history
- Discount status
- Meeting points
- Digital participation.
The price itself is fluid, personalized and behavioral.
This is not a classic ration. But it is a new form of economic control.
⸻
Of course, commercial chains argue in a business context:
- Persistently low prices are difficult to finance.
- Actions enabled competition.
- Customers wanted the feeling of saving money.
- Data-based systems have increased efficiency.
This is partially true.
And yet, a fundamental societal question remains.
Why is access to affordable basic services increasingly linked to attention?
Or, even more fundamentally:
Why do people need to use a growing part of their mental energy to optimize food mechanics?
Because this energy is lacking elsewhere.
- family,
- Education
- Community
- political participation
- Creativity
- Quiet.
- It's a must.
- inner development
The modern consumer society thus creates a subtle form of permanent employment: points, Pickerl, coupons, bonus levels, Cashback, Loyalty actions.
Not from a great conspiracy, but because attention itself has become an economic resource.
⸻
The historical food brand was created from material scarcity.
Paradoxically, the modern discount ecosystem emerges in abundance.
And maybe that's where the deepest irritation lies: The fact that highly productive societies with full shelves still produce systems in which people have to use a growing part of their life energy to organize access to "favorable normal".
The actual question, therefore, might not be:
"Are today's discount programs like previous food brands?"
But:
What kind of society arises when even basic services are increasingly linked to behavioral management, data integration and permanent self-optimization?
For a society does not only show itself by whether there is food.
It's also about, how much lifetime a person has to spend, to reach them in dignity.